Mixed Sugar Fermentation by Clostridia and Metabolic Engineering for Butanol Production
T.C. Ezeji, ... N. Qureshi, in Biorefineries, 2014
9.2 Mixed-Sugar Fermentation by Solventogenic Clostridia
In addition to the various carbohydrate substrates mentioned in the introduction of this chapter, butanol can be produced from sugarcane and beet molasses, whey permeate containing lactose, soy molasses, Jerusalem artichoke, corn, and starchy root crops. However, the prices of some of these renewable feedstocks are high and the production of biofuel from them would not be economical, because substrate price is the factor that most significantly affects the economy of biofuel production [12–14]. The use of economically available agricultural residues such as wheat straw, barley straw, corn stover, miscanthus, and switchgrass offers an alternative to using these higher-value substrates. Fermentation of the residues requires pretreatment with dilute sulfuric acid or alkali at high temperature, however, because pretreatment alters the cellulosic biomass structure, making the biomass fibers accessible to the hydrolytic enzymes that release hexose and pentose sugars from the biomass. These fibrous biomass residues contain approximately 30-40% hexoses and 25-30% pentoses. Given that pentose sugars (arabinose and xylose) form a significant part of the biomass, the economics are not favorable if these sugars are not utilized by the culture. This need for pentose utilization is a challenge that has plagued the biomass-to-ethanol process. Hence, the basic objective of this section is to review the pentose-fermentation capabilities of butanol-producing cultures.
Waksman and Kirsh [15] were among the first to report the production of acetone and butanol (AB) from cellulosic or hemicellulosic hydrolyzates, with the process emerging in 1933, followed by xylose fermentation [16,17]. Between 1960 and 1980, few published reports addressed the fermentation of pentoses such as xylose especially as it related to AB. In early 1980s, the fermentation of cellulosic hydrolyzate into butanol gained momentum, and soon several reports were published. In 1982, Soni et al. [18] hydrolyzed bagasse and rice straw to produce AB in batch cultures of Clostridium saccharoperbutylacetonicum. In these studies individual hexose and pentose sugars were not measured, but the authors presumed that the culture utilized both types of sugars for AB production. In a batch system, 17.1 g/L AB was produced with a product yield of 0.34, and the initial and final sugar concentrations in the fermentation medium were 60.0 and 6.0 g/L, respectively. This study was followed by a number of studies that achieved fermentation through the use of either model sugar solutions containing cellulosic sugars or actual cellulosic hydrolyzates [19–21]. Reporting on one such study, Mes-Hartree and Saddler indicated that butanol values of approximately 90% of the theoretical yield were achieved when glucose was used as a substrate [19]. It was also reported that butanol production using five other sugars produced differing yields. Listed in order of decreasing yield, the sugars used were cellobiose, mannose, arabinose, xylose, and galactose. This result indicated that the fermentation of pentose sugars was possible, but to a lesser extent.
In a study, butanol was produced from Pinus radiata (wood) hydrolyzate, which required detoxification prior to fermentation using activated carbon, as well as cation and anion exchange resins. In this study, a maximum butanol concentration of 5.7 g/L was achieved with a theoretical yield of 17%. Although individual sugar concentrations before fermentation were measured, no account of their use for cell growth and fermentation was provided [20]. Further, Marchal et al. used wheat straw, pretreated with alkali, to produce AB using Clostridium acetobutylicum in a single reactor in which hydrolysis and fermentation were combined [21]. For the hydrolysis of cellulosic fibers into individual sugars, a cellulase enzyme from Trichoderma reesei was employed, and the combined hydrolysis and fermentation system produced 17.3 g/L AB. Individual sugars (glucose, cellobiose, xylose, and arabinose) were measured during hydrolysis and fermentation, and Marchal and colleagues demonstrated that all the sugars were used by the culture to produce AB, with the utilization of xylose being slow or incomplete.
In another study on the continuous production of butanol, Groot and Luyben [22] used immobilized cells of Clostridium species DSM 2152 to ferment a mixture of glucose and xylose, and they reported that xylose was utilized by the culture after glucose was completely consumed. Groot and Luyben also noted that, after 700 h of fermentation, the utilization of xylose slowed down. More recently, Qureshi et al. [23, 24] and Ezeji and Blaschek [7] showed that C. acetobutylicum P260 (renamed C. beijerinckii P260) and C. beijerinckii BA101 preferred glucose over xylose. Qureshi et al. [24] produced butanol in an integrated hydrolysis, fermentation, and product recovery system using wheat straw as a substrate. After wheat straw sugars were completely utilized, the bioreactor was continuously fed with a mixture of glucose, xylose, arabinose, galactose, and mannose in a ratio similar to the sugar ratio of wheat straw in order to mimic wheat straw hydrolyzate conditions. After a period of about 200 h, the utilization of xylose was reduced, and xylose accumulated in the fermentation broth. At about 400 h, xylose utilization was considerably reduced, and it completely stopped at 533 h, even though no other sugars were present in the reactor at that time.
Plants in the Soviet Union produced acetone and butanol from molasses and rye starch until 1980 [25]. In a process not published until 2006, these plants used agricultural residues such as hemp waste, corncobs, and sunflower shells to produce this biofuel after hydrolysis [25]. The residues were milled into powder and then hydrolyzed with dilute sulfuric acid for 1.5-3 h, depending upon substrate of choice. Corncobs were hydrolyzed more easily than the others. The so-called pentose hydrolyzates were neutralized with Ca(OH)2 (lime) followed by the addition of these hydrolyzates to rye flour or molasses for fermentation. Fermentation times were observed to increase when pentose hydrolyzates were added to molasses or rye flour. In these fermentations the composition of ABE from the fermentation of pentose hydrolyzates shifted toward ethanol production.
In the early 1990s, a significant number of studies were performed on the production of AB from agricultural hydrolyzates such as corncobs [26]. While testing the various inocula ratios (1.25-10%) in a 4-liter bioreactor, researchers observed that the culture used 38.0-39.1 g/L glucose and 7.1-14.8 g/L xylose to produce 13.5-17.9 g/L total ABE. The reactor inoculated with 10% inoculum used the largest amount of xylose (14.8 g/L) and produced 17.9 g/L total ABE in 38 h of fermentation. The utilization of arabinose ranged from 0 (1.25% inocula) to 0.2 g/L (10% inocula). These studies were performed in batch reactors, however, and the culture in such reactors utilizes a significant amount of xylose as compared to a culture in a continuous reactor.
Studies on the use of hexose and pentose sugars for butanol production suggested that butanol-producing cultures have limited capability to utilize pentose sugars, with fermentation of xylose being most limited [19,21,24]. If these cultures are employed to produce butanol on a continuous basis, they could stop fermenting xylose, thus resulting in the loss of significant amounts of cellulosic sugars. To utilize all the cellulosic sugars in continuous, long-term fermentations, cultures were developed using metabolic engineering techniques to enhance capability of butanol production from mixed sugars. The details of these studies, along with elimination of acetone production, are described in Section 9.3 of this chapter.